Top 10 Pencil Eyeliners for Mature Eyes
2025’s Best Waterproof Pencil Eyeliners for Mature Eyes
After extensive research and testing, we’ve identified the best waterproof pencil eyeliner specifically designed for mature eyes. Whether you struggle with sensitivity, fine lines, or hooded lids, we’ve curated the top-performing option to enhance your eyes effortlessly.
Finding the Right Eyeliner for Mature Eyes
As our skin changes, so do our makeup needs—especially when it comes to eyeliner. What once glided on effortlessly may now tug, smudge, or fade too quickly. Fine lines, hooded lids, and sensitivity can make it harder to find an eyeliner that applies smoothly, stays put, and enhances the eyes without irritation. With so many options available, it’s difficult to know which ones truly deliver and which ones fall short.
To cut through the noise, we teamed up with beauty experts, makeup artists, and real users to test some of the most popular eyeliners on the market. Our goal was to find a formula that offers precision, long-lasting wear, and a comfortable application—without pulling or smudging.
What we found was a mix — some eyeliners applied beautifully and stayed in place all day, while others faded, transferred, or were simply too harsh on delicate skin. But one eyeliner stood out from the rest, delivering smooth, smudge-proof definition that’s perfect for mature eyes. Read on to discover which eyeliners lived up to their promises, which didn’t, and most importantly, which one was the best choice for mature eyes.
Rumi LushLine+ Waterproof Eyeliner
1. LushLine + Waterproof Eyeliner ($24.65) - Rumi Cosmetiques
After testing numerous eyeliners, LushLine+ Waterproof Eyeliner quickly became our favorite. Designed specifically for mature eyes, it delivers smooth, effortless application without tugging or skipping. From the first use, it was clear this eyeliner was different—it glides on seamlessly, providing rich, long-lasting color without settling into fine lines or smudging throughout the day.
One of its standout features is its creamy, waterproof formula that stays put without fading or transferring. Whether applied to the lash line or waterline, it maintains a crisp, defined look without irritation. The built-in sharpener ensures a precise tip for every use, while the smudge tip allows for effortless blending to create a softer, more natural effect.
We were particularly impressed with how well LushLine+ held up through long days, humidity, and even occasional watery eyes. Despite its all-day wear, it removes easily at night without excessive rubbing or irritation. This makes it the perfect choice for those looking for an eyeliner that enhances their eyes with ease, comfort, and lasting definition.
Designed for Mature Eyes
Waterproof & Smudge-proof
Built-in Sharpener and Smudge Tip
Nourishing Ingredients
Hypoallergenic Formula
Perfect for Hooded Eyes
Limited Shade Options
Premium price available only with subscription
2. Stay All Day® Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner ($24) - Stila
After testing, we were impressed with how bold and long-lasting this eyeliner is. But it does come with a few drawbacks. Removing it can be a challenge, especially without an oil-based remover, and it may dry out quickly if not stored properly. Those with sensitive eyes might find it a bit harsh, and over time, the tip can fray, flake, or crack, making application less precise.
Long-Lasting Formula
Highly Pigmented
Waterproof & Transfer-Proof
Difficult to Remove
Can Dry Out Quickly
Not Ideal for Sensitive Eyes
Tip Can Fray Over Time
Can Flake or Crack
3. PrimeEyes Glide Eyeliner ($29) - Prime Prometics
PrimeEyes Glide Eyeliner impressed us with its smooth, gel-creme formula that glides effortlessly, making it ideal for delicate or textured eyelids. The water-resistant, smudge-proof wear holds up well, and its hypoallergenic formula is great for sensitive eyes. However, it’s not fully waterproof, may require touch-ups, and needs a separate sharpener, which some may find inconvenient.
Easy & Precise Application
Hypoallergenic & Ophthalmologist Tested
Water-resistant and Smudge-proof
While Water-Resistant, it is not fully waterproof
May require Multiple Applications
Can Smudge on Lower Lash Line
Limited Long-Lasting for Some
Separate Sharpener
4. Drama Liqui-Pencil Dramatic Eyeliner ($26) - Lancome Paris
This eyeliner stood out for its bold pigmentation and smooth, creamy application. However, during testing, we found that it sets very quickly, which can make blending tricky. It also requires frequent sharpening, and those with oily lids may experience some transfer. While removal takes extra effort, its rich color payoff and lasting power make it a solid choice for those who prioritize bold definition.
Smooth, Creamy Formula
Waterproof & Long-Lasting
Variety of Finishes
Sets Too Quickly
Can Be Difficult to Remove
Sharpens Down Quickly
May Transfer on Oily Lids
Limited Precision
5. Long-Wear Cream Eyeliner Stick ($34) - Bobbi Brown
When we tried the Long-Wear Cream Eyeliner Stick, we really liked it`s 24-hour waterproof formula and smooth application. That being said, some found the formula slightly stiff on application, requiring extra effort to apply smoothly. It also sharpens down quickly, leading to more frequent touch-ups, and may transfer on oily lids over time.
24-Hour Wear
Smooth, Creamy Formula
Waterproof & Smudge-Proof
Expensive
Can Feel Stiff on Application
Sharpens Down Quickly
May Transfer on Oily Lids
Limited Precision
6. Pro-Last Waterproof, Up to 24HR Pencil Eyeliner ($9.99) - L'oreal Paris
When we tested the Pro-Last Waterproof Pencil Eyeliner, we found it delivers on its promise of long wear at an affordable price. On the downside, some users reported inconsistencies in the formula, with certain shades performing better than others. It’s also difficult to sharpen, prone to breakage, and not retractable, making it less convenient for daily use.
Affordable Price
Waterproof & Long-Lasting
Multiple Shade Options
Client Experiences
Misleading Packaging
Difficult to Sharpen
Breakage Issues
Inconsistent Formula
Removal Challenges
Not Retractable
7. Infinity Waterproof™ Eyeliner ($24) - Thrive Causemetics
When we tested the Infinity Waterproof Eyeliner, we liked its long-lasting, smudge-proof wear and the convenience of its twist-up design. However, the texture felt stiffer than expected, making application less smooth. While it holds up well, those with oily lids might experience some transfer.
Waterproof & Smudge-Proof
Twist-Up Mechanism
Cruelty-Free & Vegan
Infused with Skincare Ingredients
Not as Smooth as Advertised
Formula Can Be Stiff
Limited Shade Options for Natural Looks
Difficult to Remove
May Transfer on Oily Lids
8. High Impact™ Easy Liquid Eyeliner ($28) - Clinique
When we tried the High Impact™ Easy Liquid Eyeliner, we were impressed by its ultra-fine precision brush and bold pigmentation. On the downside, the formula can be watery at times, leading to uneven application. The cap design isn’t the best, and the liner tends to dry out quickly. Removal requires extra effort, and the limited shade range may not suit everyone.
Highly Pigmented
Long-Lasting & Waterproof
Safe for Sensitive Eyes
Fragrance-Free & Allergy-Tested
Watery Formula Issues
Cap Design is Flawed
Dries Out Quickly
Can Be Difficult to Remove
Not Ideal for Beginners
Limited Shade Options
9. Double Wear24H Waterproof Gel Eye Pencil ($32) - Estee Lauder
After testing the Double Wear 24H Waterproof Gel Eye Pencil, we found its pigmentation rich and application smooth. On the downside, it dries down fast, leaving little time for blending, and some users found it difficult to sharpen.
Intense Pigmentation
Waterproof & Long-Lasting
Free of Parabens, Phthalates & Fragrance
Smudger Tip for Versatility
Customer Experiences
Difficult to Sharpen
Sets Too Quickly
Formula Feels Dry Over Time
Not as Smudge-Proof as Claimed
Sharpener Not Included
10. INKcredible Waterproof Gel Eyeliner Pencil ($14) - Laura Geller
In our experience with the INKcredible Waterproof Gel Eyeliner Pencil, its creamy texture, smudge-proof wear, and built-in sharpener stood out as convenient features. That said, the quality varies across shades, and some users found it runs out quickly.
Waterproof & Smudge-Proof
Built-In Sharpener
Available in Multiple Shades
Safe for Tightlining
Creamy Formula
Can Smudge on Oily Lids
Inconsistent Quality Across Shades
Product Runs Out Quickly
Difficult to Remove
Not as Long-Wearing as Advertised
Final Verdict: Best Waterproof Pencil Eyeliner for Mature Eyes
After extensive research and testing, Rumi Cosmetiques' LushLine+ Waterproof Pecnil Eyeliner stands out as a top choice for mature and sensitive eyes, offering long-lasting wear, a smudge-proof formula, and nourishing ingredients. Unlike many competitors, it is specifically designed for older eyes, ensuring smooth application without tugging.
Rumi Cosmetiques
Others
Designed for Mature Eyes
Ease of Application
Lash-Nourishing Ingredients
Ease of Removal
Price = Quality
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Rumi LushLine+ the best pencil eyeliner for mature eyes?
Yes! It is considered one of the best eyeliners for mature eyes because it applies effortlessly without pulling on delicate eyelids. The creamy formula ensures smooth application while staying put all day without smudging.
Is Rumi LushLine+ good for hooded eyes?
Yes! The best eyeliner for hooded eyes needs to be quick-drying and transfer-proof, and Rumi LushLine+ stays in place without smearing onto the upper lid, making it an ideal choice.
Can I use Rumi LushLine+ on my waterline?
Absolutely! Rumi LushLine+ Waterproof Eyeliner is safe for the waterline and provides rich color payoff that stays put without irritating the eyes.
Is Rumi LushLine+ Eyeliner safe for sensitive eyes?
Yes! It is ophthalmologist-tested, hypoallergenic, and free from harsh ingredients, making it one of the best eyeliners for sensitive eyes and for those who wear contact lenses.
Where can I buy Rumi LushLine+ Waterproof Eyeliner?
You can purchase Rumi LushLine+ directly from the official Rumi Cosmetiques website and selected authorized beauty retailers.
This comparison website is operated by Rumi Cosmetiques, that distributes products that are listed on this website.